Judge orders 4 men held in former Marine’s death
by Lindsay Field
lfield@mdjonline.com
May 19, 2012 12:06 AM | 3605 views | 28 28 comments | 14 14 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Three of the men being held in the beating death of former Cobb Marine Zach Gamble — from left: Jason Scott Hill, 35, Arthur Lynell Batchelor, 37, and Sean DGen Hall, 38 — sit with Aaron Henrickson, Hill's attorney, at Friday’s probable cause hearing.<br>Staff/Jon-Michael Sullivan
view slideshow (3 images)
MARIETTA — A cocaine-fueled birthday party, terrifying war stories and a vulgar text message led to the beating death of former Marine Zach Gamble, 34, of Acworth, on March 25, prosecutors said Friday.

Cobb Assistant District Attorney Marc Cella presented the evidence before Cobb Magistrate Court Judge Frank Cox during a probable cause hearing, which ended with four Cobb men behind bars, waiting to see if they will be prosecuted in Gamble’s death.

Cox ruled that there is enough evidence to keep the four men — Sean DGen Hall, 38, of Mableton; Tarell Winston Secrest, 36, of Marietta; Jason Scott Hill, 35, of Marietta; and Arthur Lynell Batchelor, 37, of Acworth — locked up while he sent the case to a grand jury.

Cox denied bond for all four.

Detective John Dawes with Cobb Police summarized for the court the account of the night of Gamble’s death he pieced together by interviewing the defendants and others with knowledge of the evening.

Dawes said the four men were gathered at the apartment where Secrest was living with his fiancee in Concord Chase Apartments in Smyrna for Secrest’s birthday party, but Gamble was asked to leave just after 5 the morning because he was telling war stories about seeing women and children killed while he was serving in the Middle East.

Dawes said Gamble sent Secrest, who he’s known for about 20 years, a text message shortly after that that said “piece of s---,” after which the four defendants went down to the parking lot and confronted Gamble.

Dawes said he thinks Gamble struck one of the defendants first, and then the four men hit and possibly kicked him repeatedly.

Gamble was found unresponsive in the apartment complex parking lot by a cab driver just before 6:15 a.m. that day. He was taken to WellStar Kennestone Hospital in Marietta, underwent surgery that night and was pronounced dead from blunt force trauma on April 8.

“The manner of death is believed to be homicide, and the cause of death is believed to be associated with blunt force trauma,” Dawes said. “That included (three) skull fractures … The only other injuries I identified were prominent bruising that came up on his left bicep and shoulder and a wide bruise along the back of his right knee.”

He said he never saw any defensive injuries to Gamble’s hands or arms during his visits to the hospital, which would have indicated that he tried to defend himself.

Dawes said that two times during the night of the incident, Secrest, Gamble and Batchelor left the apartment to go buy cocaine in Secrest’s fiancee’s car. While no one apparently saw the three ever using the drug, nor was evidence of it found in the apartment or the vehicle, Dawes said it should show up in the medical examiner’s toxicology report, which hasn’t been released.

Each of the four defendants had their own attorney, whose questions focused on what blows Dawes believes their clients were responsible for.

Batchelor has previously been arrested on charges of reckless driving and possession of marijuana with an intent to distribute, Cox pointed out in denying bond.

A trial date has not been set, but Cobb County Superior Court Judge Dorothy A. Robinson is expected to preside over it.
Comments
(28)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Completely disgusted
|
June 13, 2012
Yes, there is probably more to the story than the media is sharing. Would you expect anything less? There is nothing that will justify beating him to death. People don't think of the consequences for their actions. It makes me sick knowing that his friends, two of which, he has known most of his life, could do such a horrific thing. These four cowards stole his life, cheated his son out of a father and just threw away their own life. Leaving behind their own families to pick up the pieces. Disagreement or not, they should have handled it like adults. Seeing them on camera, can you see any remorse on their face? All I saw was some punk rolling his eyes. I hope they show them pictures of him in the hospital on life support, laying in his coffin.I want this to be their only reality. I want them to suffer as his family suffers every day.
Grant McNulty
|
March 18, 2013
Zach was my cousin. What they dont understand is that EVERY DAY my aunt crys now, and nothing will ever make that go away. the part about him making the first blow is a bunch of crap THERE WASNT EVEN A SCRATCH ON THE OTHER GUYS!
SoSad123
|
June 07, 2012
There was nothing said or done above that would justify 4 men beating 1. These men have obviously admitted guilt in the incident and now are trying to save their butts. I can't wait for the autopsy report to see if this marine did have drugs in his system. The reckless actions of these men caused one to die and multiple families to suffer! I pray all of these families can find peace for the pain they are going through...
Jessebuggy
|
May 20, 2012
Just sickening! Trying to defend yourself using a dead man's actions that is not here to speak for himself. It is murder and that is all there is to it. These four men had ample time to get their stories straight all the while lying to police and posting prayers for Zach on their Facebook pages. I don't care if he was drinking, telling war stories, or texting. None of those are reason to beat a man so severly that he never regains consciousness and his family is forced to take him off life support. There is a video on WSBTV.com that showes the "friend" rolling his eyes as the homicide detective testifies. I pray that they all get the maximum penalty.
Rubbish
|
May 22, 2012
Jesse,

I hope your comment was not directed towards me, because I was in no way trying to use Zach's actions as a reason to justify what happened. I was saying that there is more to the story than what the media is printing, and those who were actually in the court room that day heard it. The media picks and chooses what they want to print. I apologize if it seems in any way I was disrespecting Zach. Now that I look back at what I said, I see I could have written it a bit more lighter, and that for that I apologize.

That being said, unless you were there personally then you do not know exactly what happened, if it was 4 on 1, etc. His friend rolled his eyes because the detective claimed they freaked out and jumped in. It looked to me like he was rolling his eyes in disbelief to what the detective was saying, and unless you are God or you were there, then you don't know the full story! Let the justice system do its job and remember the law in country: Innocent until Proven Guilty.
anonymous
|
March 18, 2013
I agree, and not just because im his cousin, but because to kill a man and act like its nothing while his family suffers? DUde.....................
Rubbish
|
May 20, 2012
Once again, you people go by everything the media prints, and believe it word for word. If any of you were in the courthouse, you would have known that it was not 4 on 1. Zach attacked one at first, knocked him down and wouldn't stop, and went for another. I guess it's just too hard to believe that he could do that as well as get so coked out of his mind that he started reliving war stories right? No disrespect to Zach or to any of his families or friends, but get the story straight before you start claiming that there's "NO WAY." As friends of the defendants, I feel the same way. There is NO WAY they could have done this the way the media is portraying, and I am sick of this one-sided story. Your angel boy marine was no angel.
mk-give me a break!
|
May 21, 2012
This man served this country to protect freedoms that give idiots like you a right to say idiotic things!

You protect a culture that beats a guy to death, because they don't like what he says?

Boy, we really are in trouble!

Too bad Zach isn't here to tell HIS side of tthis lopsided tale!

4 against 1,.. PERIOD!

Put em all away- we don't need these thugs walking around our community!
Jessebuggy
|
May 22, 2012
As a friend of one of the accused, I feel sorry for you for being friends with such men that would beat a man and leave him for dead and lie to the police when questioned. Detective Dawes testified that Zach had no injuries to his hands and no defensive wounds. Do NOT say that they did not beat him to death and leave him and lie about it! They did and then continued on with their daily lives as if it didn't matter. Whether they receive justice here, they will receive it in eternity and rot in hell. They did not destroy just one family, they left a legacy for their loved ones that will live on. They committed murder!
angry4678
|
May 20, 2012
I completely disagree with this article; I knew him personally and never heard him talk about Iraq unless asked and even then it would be brief responses.... these thugs must have good lawyers to suggest such a defense.... truth is they were probably all drunk.. but that doesn't excuse taking a man's life; especially a marine who has done more for his country than most of us have... further more if they all knew eachother what compelled them to leave him for dead? Sounds like a mob beating to me and any other rational person who understands the law
angry4678
|
May 19, 2012
I completely disagree with this article; I knew him personally and never heard him talk about Iraq unless asked and even then it would be brief responses.... these thugs must have good lawyers to suggest such a defense.... truth is they were probably all drunk.. but that doesn't excuse taking a man's life; especially a marine who has done more for his country than most of us have... further more if they all knew eachother what compelled them to leave him for dead? Sounds like a mob beating to me and any other rational person who understands the law
angry4678
|
May 20, 2012
They are attempting to deflect the outrage that comes with four degenerates killing a man who served his country not once; but twice
West Cobb Resident
|
May 19, 2012
What a tragic story. A person's death over basically nothing. What a bunch of losers.
Frankie58
|
May 19, 2012
Ok, let me get this straight, this guy was beaten to death because of TEXT MESSAGE. Defense is asking "which blow killed him and by who"...please... THEY ALL are complaisant in this MURDER, they all need to be charge equally, at ANY time one of them could have stopped the others. And what makes matters worse, one of these cowards knew Gamble for twenty years, they beat him down and then left him for dead, ya, real men here.. 4 against one and then they all run and hide......
reno88
|
May 19, 2012
typical africans. can't fight one-on-one. they have to gang up on the victim. hate crime? you bet, but don't count on it prosecuted that way.

hopefully the arrests - and convictions - will give the family some peace.
anonymous
|
May 19, 2012
The savagery of the hood culture.

Another young black man killed by another young black man (plus 3). Their lives matter only when they are snuffed out by someone who has a skin color lighter than their own.

They are their own worst enemy...and no one cares. Sad.
Wrong Answer
|
May 20, 2012
The victim was white.
mk-
|
May 19, 2012
4 black guys jump a white guy in a parking lot. No injuries of Gamble defending himself and fighting back.

Why aren't these thugs being charged w/ a hate crime?
Jessebuggy
|
May 20, 2012
Because Obama would never come out and say that "if he had a son he would look like one of these 4 men" and Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson won't be showing up to defend the killing of a white man.
johnccccc
|
September 18, 2012
because it is not a hate crime, just because they are a different color. a hate crime requires prejudicial hatred to be a motive in the crime. Gamble and his attackers were friends, celebrating a birthday party together, who clearly had a falling out at some point in the night. thats what led to the beating, or so it seems from the evidence.
Southern Patriot
|
May 19, 2012
If you lie down with dogs you'll wake up with fleas, or perhaps worse. His life style and choice of "friends" lead to his death, he has only himself to blame.
Jessebuggy
|
May 20, 2012
Wow -- I sure hope one of your children never makes a wrong choice of friends. I guess you would stand at your child's grave and say well buddy, you asked for it.
At least respectful
|
May 20, 2012
Really??? This family is suffering the murder of their son at the hands of someone he knew for most of his life! He was a great person - you have no idea!!! This guy wasn't a bad person at all! Far from it!!! He brought his squad safely through Iraq (2 tours) only to be beaten by these thugs and left for dead! Next party you attend I hope no one decides you have fleas! I cannot believe the ignorance of anyone who makes such remarks as if to say any victim of crime deserves what he gets!
Rubbish
|
May 22, 2012
I fully believe in innocent until proven guilty, and that media is having a field day trying to stir up as much drama as possible, but what you just said is absolutely ridiculous! So because he attends a birthday party of someone he has known since middle school he is lying down with dogs? This could have happened to anyone, anywhere, and anytime. What a pathetic thing to say about someone who lost his life for no good reason.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides