EMC members try to take back electric co-op
by Kathryn Malone
kmalone@mdjonline.com
March 17, 2011 12:00 AM | 4586 views | 16 16 comments | 21 21 recommendations | email to a friend | print
MARIETTA - A group of Cobb EMC members are vowing to take back the Marietta-based electric cooperative through a petition drive that could potentially spark the election of a new board.

With the help of the Georgia Sierra Club, EMC members have begun circulating a petition that calls for removal of one or all co-op directors at a special meeting on May 21. According to Cobb EMC bylaws, if the petition garners signatures from 10 percent of the EMC's members, then members can vote at a special meeting to oust incumbents and elect new directors. With more than 193,000 members in Cobb, Cherokee, Fulton, Bartow and Paulding counties, the petition would need nearly 20,000 signatures to reach the 10 percent mark.

A petition drive kickoff event will take place Saturday from 11:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. at East Cobb Park on Roswell Road. Cobb EMC members are encouraged to participate in the event to pick up petition packets and to sign up to canvass their neighborhoods.

Erin Glynn, national representative for the Sierra Club in Georgia, said the petition drive is a culmination of a year of work and frustration over inaction by Cobb EMC.

"We've all been frustrated and constantly thinking, 'well, what can we do now?'" Glynn said. "There's been no election, there's been no member meeting. We've been examining the bylaws and putting our heads together to see how we can change this thing ... Something like this petition drive is actually something that gives the power back to the EMC members."

Glynn said the Sierra Club has been working with some of its 1,200 members in Cobb EMC's service area to draft a petition and help EMC members take action against Cobb EMC's embattled leaders.

All 10 directors on the Cobb EMC board came up for election at the end of 2010. That's because the last three annual elections have been postponed due to a civil lawsuit filed by Cobb EMC members and subsequent appeals.

Glynn said she and the group she's working with would like to see current EMC directors step down and allow an open election where reform candidates have a fair chance. She does worry even if the petitioners collect the necessary 20,000 signatures that the current board will just change its bylaws and deny members an open election.

"Whatever we do, Cobb EMC is going to say it's wrong," Glynn said. "This is going to be an example in ambition and drive. Whether it actually is taken up by the EMC - it's really up in the air. I don't have a crystal ball. The bylaws state that we can do this, so we're going to do it." There's also the issue of whether the courts would allow a petition-driven election to occur. A December 2008 settlement in the civil suit called for specific actions to be taken regarding how directors could be elected going forward. Once that is determined, the postponed '08 election was to occur. However, Cobb EMC directors made bylaw amendments just days after the settlement, which plaintiffs attorneys said went against the agreement. That all remains pending a decision from the Georgia Supreme Court.

EMC attorney Dwight Davis said he believes the petition could not apply to - at least - the directors in the '08 election, and that the organizers should check with courts before moving forward with the petition.

But Glynn said, "The petition campaign is wholly separate and will neither affect nor be effected by the various lawsuits. The ability to petition is given to members in the bylaws of Cobb EMC and do not have anything to do with what is going on in the courts."

Mark Hackett, a Cobb EMC member for 13 years, said he remembers when Dwight Brown, Cobb EMC's former president and CEO who was recently indicted on multiple counts of theft and racketeering, formed the for-profit corporation Cobb Energy in the 1990s. He said he watched as it became a cash cow for Brown and board members.

"I'm outraged," Hackett, an east Cobb resident, said. "We've got a situation where Cobb Energy spent $20 million to put their name on the Cobb Energy Center. That's $20 million of Cobb EMC's money and they're advertising like they're coca-cola. And the members really didn't have a choice. The board that has presided over this fiasco aren't going up for election ... and it's not clear when there's going to be an election."

The Georgia Supreme Court decision, expected in the summer, could pave the way for the postponed elections.

Hackett, who spent his 20-year career in the energy industry, said he believes that Cobb EMC needs a new board that is focused on bringing power to members for a good price. He said he learned about the petition drive on Monday and has already started collecting signatures from his neighbors.

Dan Davis, a Cobb EMC member for 11 years, said he started researching Cobb EMC, Brown and the board about five years ago, when articles began to surface about Cobb Energy.

Dan Davis, a northeast Cobb resident, said he didn't believe the relationship between Cobb EMC and Cobb Energy was jiving, per bylaws.

"I was pretty convinced that the board and leadership had basically hijacked the co-op and moved all of its assets over to Cobb Energy, and were very clearly benefiting themselves through preferred stocks and high salaries and retirement benefits," he said. "The profit wasn't coming back to the co-op as far as I could tell."

Dan Davis believes Cobb EMC members' rights have been violated.

The EMC customers who brought the lawsuit in 2007 alleged breach of fiduciary duty, gross mismanagement, waste of corporate assets and unjust enrichment in relation to the management and operations of the co-op and Cobb Energy. The settlement in the case brought Cobb Energy back under the umbrella of the co-op.

While the Sierra Club has been a driving force behind the petition, Davis said this isn't an effort of any environmental group, but an attempt by members to take back their co-op.

"This is not two or three or four environmental groups coming together to put a wedge in between the board and the members," he said.

The Sierra Club opposes Cobb EMC's plans to build a coal-fired power plant in middle Georgia.

GreenLaw and the Southern Environmental Law Center have represented Sierra Club's Georgia Chapter, the Fall-line Alliance for a Clean Environment, Ogeechee Riverkeeper, and the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy in challenging the issuance of permits for the plant.

Comments
(16)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
J2131
|
March 24, 2011
Cobb EMC has tried all kinds of devisive tactics to divert attention from their actions. At the meeting held after the AJC reported on concerns about Cobb EMC, they warned " you don't want Atlanta telling us what to do ". Now they are trying to link the recall to the Sierra Club (oh, no gasp!) Well , good for the Sierra Club and anyone else who wants to help--this is NOT ABOUT the Sierra Club and they know it. Only Cobb EMC members can throw out the directors. There are plenty of outrageous facts that ought to be the focus - let's keep on the FACTS --what Dwight Brown did --he and the board need to GO!! NOW !
anonymous
|
March 18, 2011
The current thugs will keep our electric rates at a reasonable rate. An EMC board loaded with seirra club approved directors will do what they can to turn Cobb EMC into a windmill farm or otherwise put them out of business (trying to save the earth). Cobb EMC customers will be paying for the nonsense.

Be careful folks. Understand what your comrades motives really are.

anonymous
|
March 18, 2011
Hope you guys have a lot of stamps, cause your gonna have to mail out, according to the bylaws, written notice to every member at Cobb EMC.

Written or printed notice stating the place, day and hour of

the meeting and, in case of a special meeting, the purpose or purposes for which the meeting is called, shall be

delivered not less than seven (7) days nor more than twenty (20) days before the date of the meeting, either personally

or by mail, by or at the direction of the Secretary, or by the persons calling the meeting, to each member; provided,

however, that with respect to all meetings at which directors are to be elected, such notice shall be so delivered

not less than seven (7) days nor more than twenty (20) days before the date of the meeting.

I guess you could hand deliver them.
David Lombrozo
|
March 17, 2011
I support all groups of CobbEMC members who understand that the purpose of the Board is to oversee the EMC to protect the members investments. It has been obvious for too long that this current Board resents its members rather than represents them.

As an independent candidate for the Cobb EMC Board, I will not subvert the CobbEMC's mission to hidden agendas. Unlike the current board, I will change the bylaws to ensure that business is handled openly, elections are fair and Directors on the Board cannot enrich themselves from the members payments.
anonymous
|
March 17, 2011
anonymouseCobb,

So you care about in all those great things. I guess innocent until proven guilty is not something you care about. You call these people you do not even know crooks and unless I missed something no one has been convicted of a crime.



These environmental groups will cause your energy cost to increase. Don’t take my word for it research Georgia Power’s latest rate increase and see what you find.

The bottom line is..
|
March 17, 2011
Cobb EMC members are smart enough to evaluate this petition on its own merits. The bottom line is we need these guys out, and we need new leadership ASAP.
anonymouseCobb
|
March 17, 2011
I don't care who runs efforts to get rid of these bums currently running CobbEMC. they are crooks running rough-shod over our best interest with our own money. Can't we all just get along and work to elect candidates who represent the common good? I happen to care about clean air and clean water too and guess what? I'm a Republican! I also care about good governance and smart leadership - something Cobb emc is NOT.
Oh Please
|
March 17, 2011
A article about a GREEN organization trying to promote their GREEN politics and agenda on the GREENest day of all St. Patrick's Day. Now that is transparency....Laughable.
Single Agenda
|
March 17, 2011
To EMC Members Organizing this Petition-

I have been a critic of Brown and this board for several years now, but I will not join forces with the Sierra Club. You are making a big mistake aligning with any other named group that has another agenda, except a group of Co-op members who want to have their rightful say in their Co-Op. There are plenty of fed up EMC members that will sign this petition without being in cahoots with the Sierra Club.

Why take a chance alienating any person who would sign this petition? Another goof by EMC members that Dwight Brown and the Board are having a laugh over. Brown and the Board not only play smart, but like a sly fox. We need to out fox them at their own game.

Take Back Cobb EMC
|
March 17, 2011
This is exactly the jumpstart we, as Cobb EMC members, need to change the status quo on the board. For far too long we haven't had a voice at Cobb EMC, with the board "acting in our best interest."

Well, that's not how an electric membership co-op works. You might say you're acting in our best interest, but we deserve to find out what exactly it is you're doing.

New leadership on the board has an opportunity to provide just what we're missing: transparency and accountability. Let's take the steps to ensure that we never again lose control of OUR electric company!

Hope to see everyone on Saturday!
tell_the_truth
|
March 17, 2011
Fantastic! I for one am glad someone is doing SOMETHING... if I happen to agree with an environmental group on this one, so what? I hope people will come to the event. We can't afford to have leaders who will spare no expense to keep their positions of power... especially when it's at OUR expense.

If you want to get more information, go to Take Back Cobb EMC's website or Facebook page (just search it) and sign up for updates.
Kelley in Marietta
|
March 17, 2011
The environmental groups involved in this effort have been trying to quash Plant Washington for years and have been unable to achieve any success at the EPD or the in courts or traction with the general public. This is just another tactic these groups are using to attain their goal. It has nothing to do with the competency of the board and everything to do with their myopic agenda. They are perturbed that the board acts in the best interest of its members and not a lap dog for their cause.
anonymous
|
March 17, 2011
Yeah, the sierra club's involvement means I will NOT be signing the petition to oust the thugs in charge of Cobb EMC

I refuse to join with the leftist radicals of the sierra club to take over an electric power company...and NO, I do not believe the sierra club is just interested in "saving the environment".
Picket the Board
|
March 17, 2011
We need to out the rest of the board, make more information about them known to the public. We need to legally picket the board members homes. We need to make it uncomfortable for them after what they did and continue to do to the members.

We paid a board attorney to get us to this place. A reasonable person could surmise OUR attorney is allowing the board to work AGAINST the membership with legal maneuvering to keep the current board in power.

He's right....WE WANT "OUR" MONEY BACK!!!
anonymous
|
March 17, 2011
Great an enviromental group or groups trying to take control of a power company. And you think $4 gallon gas is tough on your budget. Think about how tough paying 20 cents kWh is going to be on your budget.

Sooner The Better
|
March 17, 2011
The whole board should be investigated and the board attorney(s) should be investigated by the GA State Bar.

This is happening all across America. There is no reason that a board for a public "non-profit" EMC should have this kind of power. A reasonable person could surmise that the politicians who set this in motion knew they were setting it up for the enrichment of board members and their cronies. How can they not be breaking bylaws when the EMC is supposedly set up to be a non-profit.

WE WANT OUR MONEY BACK!!
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides