Tough cuts ‘best recommendation’
by Lindsay Field
lfield@mdjonline.com
May 16, 2012 12:14 AM | 6638 views | 57 57 comments | 6 6 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Dr. Michael Hinojosa (MDJStaff/Laura Moon)
Dr. Michael Hinojosa (MDJStaff/Laura Moon)
slideshow
MARIETTA — Cobb Superintendent Dr. Michael Hinojosa said that while his staff has tried not to cut teaching positions and increase furlough days and class sizes to offset a projected $62 million deficit the 2013 budget, he concedes that it is “best recommendation” at this time.

“We’ve looked at so many options, and we’ve tried to incorporate where we could but this is the best recommendation under the very difficult circumstances that we have,” he said Tuesday.

During Thursday night’s meeting, the board will consider approving the FY13 budget, authorization for Hinojosa to proceed with fundraising for Teach For America for FY14, a $75,000 contract with Educations Planners, LLC of Marietta to help the district create a SPLOST IV notebook of projects, and awarding a $699,000 contract to Northside Psychological services for mental health services, which will be paid for with grant funds.

According to Mike Addison, the district’s chief financial officer, the budget has not changed and he is recommending exactly what he has been recommending since January.

For FY13, Addison has determined that there will be approximately $820.8 million in revenue collected and about $841.9 million in expenditures.

Addison is recommending the board approve cutting 350 jobs; increasing class sizes by two students and the number of furlough days from two to five; reducing the number of work days from 180 to 175; delaying raises for half a year; eliminating 50 library positions; reducing, and eventually eliminating, funding for Project 2400; and taking $21.5 million from reserves.

He said he hoped none of the school board members would request any of the suggested alternates from last week, which include reducing the furlough and instructional days from five to three and keep elementary level media parapros, but he wouldn’t be surprised.

“I would be surprised if someone didn’t at least suggest it,” he said Tuesday.

If board members amended his recommendation and approved the alternatives it could add even more to the already $62 million deficit, $7.1 million in all to be exact. Funding for those alternatives would come from the reserves, which currently stands at $99 million but would drop to almost $71 million.

“I don’t think that we need to use anymore fund balance reserves than we are,” he said. “If we use more than that, I feel like we’re cutting too deep into our safety net. I certainly don’t want to make those cuts either but you have to do what you have to do.”

In other action, Hinojosa will also be seeking permission from the board to approve his planned fundraising for a Teach For America contract in FY14.

“I’m asking them to give me permission to go out and start raising money,” he said. “I have a majority who said it’s OK and if we get the money raised, then we’ll come back with the contract in August maybe.”

In his request for authorization, Hinojosa has outlined parameters of the fundraising which includes not hiring more than 25 Teach For America teachers, adding no additional cost to the General Fund, that current Cobb teachers won’t be displaced due to these hirings and that principals at designated campuses will have the purview to hire these individuals.

Hinojosa anticipates raising approximately $200,000 this time, as opposed to the nearly $400,000 he was going to have to raise when he brought Teach For America before the board in January.

When asked whom he would be talking to about donating funds, he said he hasn’t made any moves.

“I’ve decided to just chill out and wait for authorization,” he said. “I don’t want to create a firestorm … there are some people who have expressed a desire in the past though.”

Initially, Hinojosa has said that he doesn’t plan on pursuing any Cobb companies in asking for funds but will go through Teach For America and touch base with any companies or individuals who are known for donating to the organization in the metro Atlanta already.

He also said that he wouldn’t pursue fundraising efforts, if approved by the board Thursday, until after graduation ceremonies next week.

“Hopefully things will slow down in the summer,” he said. “There’s not an urgency. I’m going to get this year closed out first.”

Lastly, Hinojosa was asked why funding for the Model School Conference scheduled for late June in Orlando, about $300,000, couldn’t be used to pay for the Teach For America training costs.

“That money that we’re using (for the conference) is either coke machine money, foundation money or professional development money,” he said.

***


In regards to the creation of a SPLOST IV notebook of projects, Hinojosa is recommending the board approve a $75,000 contract with Education Planners, which was founded by former Cobb interim superintendent James Wilson.

The company, which is located in Marietta, has an 18-member team, and their contract will run between May 18 and April 30, 2013, if approved Thursday night by the board.

Chris Ragsdale, deputy superintendent of operations, said the group would be available for assistance through the referendum vote, which the district has scheduled for March 2013.

Additionally, Ragsdale told the Facilities and Technology Committee on Monday that Education Planners would not be facilitating the program management of the project, nor do they have the option to.

“It was actually in the RFP as a condition that whoever the winning proposal was … they would in no way shape or form, be allowed to program manage any projects in Ed-SPLOST IV,” Ragsdale said.

According to district spokesperson Jay Dillon, details of the RFP application cannot be made public until after the board has voted on by the board.

Ragsdale said on Tuesday that the district will also have no need to out-source or bid out the program management of SPLOST IV and that it will be maintained by the district’s SPLOST staff, like SPLOST III is currently being managed.

“We like the way we have it,” Hinojosa said about the district’s SPLOST department handling program management. “I don’t plan to change it but if SPLOST passes, we’ll need to staff (Shepard’s) old position but we won’t know that until the vote.”

The school board approved bringing the program in-house in December 2009. That is when they hired SPLOST Administrator Doug Shepard who resigned in early March. The acting executive director is Glen Brown, who added the role his current job as director of SPLOST program management and accountability.

If voters approve the 1 percent sales tax next March for a fourth SPLOST, Ragsdale said the district estimates they will collect approximately $600 million between Jan. 1, 2014, and Dec. 31, 2018. The funds collected are similar to what is expected to be collected with SPLOST III, which began on Jan. 1, 2009, and will run through Dec. 31, 2013.

***


In other business, Deputy Superintendent of Leadership Alice Stouder is recommending the board approve a $699,054.95 contract with Northside Psychological Services between July 1 and June 30, 2013, to be paid for with a Success For All Students Grant.

The grant is contingent upon the district’s approval of a no-cost extension request that was submitted to the U.S. Department of Education, which is expected to be returned sometime in May.

***


The board will also consider approving 10 new principal hires at Cobb schools.

The vacancies, all made through the following retirements, will be filled at McClure Middle, Susan Wing; Pickett’s Mill Elementary, Sheila Chesser; Russell Elementary, Ann H. DiPetrillo; Bryant Elementary, Dr. Patrice Moore; Bullard Elementary, Sharon J. Hardin; Big Shanty Elementary, Lynne C. Hutnik; Kennesaw Elementary, Wanda Floyd; Powder Springs Elementary, Darlene Mitchell; Lovinggood Middle, Elizabeth W. Wilson; and Hollydale Elementary, Lynn McWhorter.

The names of these principal’s replacements have not been released by the district and will not be until after the board approves them, Hinojosa said.

“We don’t even have the names yet,” he said. “That’s what I’ve been doing this afternoon. We still have the research to do.”

There will also be a vacancy at Hightower Trail Middle, where Hilda Wilkins is currently the principal, but a replacement has not been named; and the principal at Sky View Elementary, which is closing at the end of this school year, Cynthia Cutler, is also retiring.

The board meeting will begin at 7 p.m. in the boardroom at 514 Glover St. in Marietta. Public comments will take place the first 30 minutes of the meeting.
Comments
(57)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
west cobb
|
May 19, 2012
I am a CCSD parapro. I work very hard helping my teacher teach and take care of your children. I love each and everyone of them and treat them as I would if they were my own children. My heart fiils with joy when their eyes light up the first time they realize they CAN read. I do work hard for my $21,000 a year. I will be at retirement age soon and will receive my approx $800 a month pension. I have owned my home for 40 years and have always paid school taxes. I will live the rest of my life on a very limited income. I believe the Cobb County tax exemption for seniors should be kept in place. Seniors will be placed in the position of losing their home. I know I will. My taxes for my house are over 10% of my income or $2400 a year. That will be 3 months of my gross pension per year for property tax. Maybe there should be an extra tax in place for people with more than one or two in school. I know of families with 8 or 9 children, living in rental homes with other families, working for cash, and not paying anything into the school system. Maybe it is time to investigate who uses the money for free breakfast/lunch, etc.
Dear CCSD Parapro
|
May 24, 2012
Dear CCSD Parapro,

First of all, thank you.

Folks like you make a strong positive tangible difference in the lives of our children. I hope you have received a great level of joy and happiness from your work.

But you are no more important than me, or my family.

You do NOT deserve a tax cut just because of your age. As a west Cobb resident, I am disgusted by the fact that you think you're worthy of a handout, and then use a fictitious boogeyman called, "families of 8 or 9 children, living in rental homes with other families" as a justification of your desire for preferential treatment.

You own a house in Cobb? Congrats. I do as well. We all should pay the same millage rate. If you wish to lobby for more senior services that is perfectly fine. But please spare us the 'holier than thou' argument.

The only person who deserves to win that one is the family that is raising good kids and providing all of us a stronger tax base for our future retirement.

Tell the TRUTH
|
May 17, 2012
Weren't "stakeholder" committees supposed to meet, interview, and then send tTHEIR administrative candidate recommendations to Hinojosa and the Board? Why am I hearing that in at least two cases Hinojosa went against the stakeholder committee recommendation? Why waste everyone's time? Over 300 hours of people's lives are nullified by Hinojosa's judgement of a candidate's "match" to a school based on sitting across from a person for less than fifteen minutes. This is another fine example of the Cobb County BOE and the superintendent wasting taxpayers' time. AND that new principal will walk into a building where people didn't vote for her. Set up schools for failure from the getgo...that's the way to improve our schools in Cobb.
S.Finch
|
May 17, 2012
I think Jesus said we're all in this by ourselves, alone with no need to help anyone. As long as you look out for number one, who cares?
Butter Bean
|
May 17, 2012
What, pray tell, is "coke machine money"?
anonymous
|
May 17, 2012
Coke machine money - a cut of the profits given to schools by the soft drink machine provider in exchange for allowing school children access to their products on school campus. Vending machines in other words. Schools negotiate a contract with a vendor, and then can choose how to allocate their cut of the profits. At the same time we bemoan the fact our kids have unhealthy eating habits and are too fat. But it's okay to sell out their health needs in order to earn some money... yea, right.
Kennesaw Reident
|
May 17, 2012
I noticed alot of discussion about the Senior Tax exemption. I believe that exemption ONLY applies to those who are 62 or older and have an income less than $30,000. Perhaps the Cobb County Tax Assessor's office could earn their pay by verifying eligibility. Anyone out there - is this the case?

If you are no longer eligible, you are supposed to self-report. Time to require some income verification I believe!!!
Kennesaw Resident
|
May 17, 2012
I think I answered my own questions - ooops! Sorry for the confustion, nonethless, the senior tax exemption needs to go away.
mk-mindless
|
May 17, 2012
The school boards and politicians just don't seem to know how to think smart any more.

If you took Teach for America philosophy one step further, you could save ALL teachers salaries, by just letting the children teach each other!!

Isn't that the idea?

Cut corners on teachers, just don't touch Dr. Hinojosas $300,000 plus per year!!

Also, wonder whose bright idea it was to close a wonderful little neighborhood elementary school in Smyrna (Brown), and spend millions on a piece of land connected to Campbell High School, to build a large, cold, forboding structure for 20 million? Give or take a few million!!

How could anyone think it smart for 1st graders to walk past a high school to get to school??

The better option would have been to spend 3-4 million each at Argyle, Belmont & Brown, updatng schools, modernizing classrooms and adding value to the neighborhoods.

That would have saved the district 10 million right there!!

The communities thrive when the neighborhood schools get support from families & school board.

Now, the children will have to driven (more obesity) or bussed (more $$ on new busses & CO2 fumes )to school.

The school is on the far side of the government buildings, that only a handful of children will walk to.

This mega school will harm Smyrnas childrens future!

getting old
|
May 17, 2012
These same people that are cutting teachers and dumbing down our already sad education system need to go! Do they not realize these kids that are give less education than they deserve will soon be running the country??? That is if there is one left to run. Get rid of these spend, spend, spend board members and put the money back in the classrooms! We don't need a bunch of people on Glover street sitting in offices while good teachers still at home on furlough. Our children (in my case grandchildren) deserve better. If H is so gung ho on fundraising why not use it to keep the great teachers we have now and not bring in newbies that don't know what they are doing?
School Calendar
|
May 16, 2012
I hear the additional furlough days will result in a a whole week off in Feburary. I can't wait to see how this plays out with the Board.
westcobb
|
May 19, 2012
Would love to see week off in Feb! Would rather see it in Sept, but will take either one.
ivotedtim
|
May 16, 2012
It seems that everyone can agree on ONE thing:

THE NON-TEACHING administration from the top down needs to take their turn at bat, take one for the team, and take a pay cut. When will the walrus acknowleged that 500 pound gorilla?

Mr.Stultz I implore you to propose this as a mechanism to conserve funds for teachers' salaries.

(BTW I mean everyone except the non teaching admin staff. How silly of me not to clarify.)
Support our Teachers
|
May 16, 2012
What is the sole purpose of a school? To educate children. Who does this job mainly fall on? The teachers. Can you have a school without teachers? Nope. So why is it okay to treat our most valuable employee this way? I will never understand why the first thing to cut is our most important asset. Fantastic teachers are continuing to leave to go to other counties where they are appreciated and treated with the respect they deserve. I am sure there are other ways to cut the budget without making the teachers carry the entire load.
HELP!
|
May 16, 2012
Is anyone asking the state for the money to board says they owe that would fix the deficit? Why are other counties getting money from the state and cobb is not?
anonymous
|
May 17, 2012
The state austerity cuts affect all Georgia public schools, not just Cobb.

Restoring austerity cuts statewide would relieve a lot of the budget pressures all districts are experiencing.

It's well past time to let Governor Deal know your feelings on this. Legislators too!

It's time Deal fulfilled his campaign promise rhetoric as a friend of public education.

Prove it Governor!
NtheNo
|
May 16, 2012
Absolutely against trying to balance the school budget on the backs of our seniors. Promises made should be kept....PERIOD. If anybody wants a fight - they'll get it from this huge voting block and from those of us that support them.
peon
|
May 16, 2012
Didn't several of the high-ranking people in the county get a large raise last year? What a way to keep the rest of the county happy.
Don Nelson
|
May 16, 2012
Every employee should share this pain, starting with all Admin. I would have recommended a 5% pay cut for all administrators, which will be repaid, if tax revenues rebound. Not enough creative thinkers in charge.
Not enough
|
May 17, 2012
They need to close down the entire system from mid-June to mid-July. There is no need to have administrators in the building and most are not there anyway. It is a waste of money to have the buildings running. That would save bundles.
anonymous
|
May 17, 2012
All employees are affected by furlough days.
non-senior parent
|
May 16, 2012
As a very high tax-paying resident with children in the system, I agree that there needs to be a serious look at the administrative cost of running the school system. Not only do we pay the taxes, but we are "encouraged" by the PTA to commit funds and guilted by the foundation to make additional donations. It used to be that the kids sold things to raise money for the foundation, but now it is just easier to have the parent write the check. I do contribute, but my inclination is to send a copy of my tax bill in the envelope. At our school, the "foundation" bought a new gym floor, which is clearly an item for the county capital budget. I really just hope everybody remembers this in November...remember the calendar, remember the school budget, and, while we're at it, let's remember that the medians were not maintained for over a year and vote out the Cobb Commission as well. Maybe then, somebody will come in and target overhead first before raping the direct costs!
Cobb Teacher
|
May 16, 2012
Teachers are made about this Teach for America mess! We are cutting certified, experienced teachers and they want to shove non-teacher candidates into our schools? This is no way to work on the achievement gap! Parents should be outraged too! They want to send these fresh out of non-education college into classrooms to self-destruct with our kids. NO Way we need this in Cobb!!
The Truth Please
|
May 16, 2012
Well, it seems original information that the funding for this summer's conference was all grant money that had to spent on professional development is no longer true. "Coke machine money" and "foundation money" could most likely be used for other purposes.

Thank you for continuing to waste money, while making the easiest cuts possible, putting it on the backs of the teachers in the classrooms. Ultimately, the students are who will pay the price. I'm sure it would be easier to do the job with less resources, than it will be with more students and fewer days. Most teachers are pretty creative.

There has to be a better way.
mental health
|
May 16, 2012
Why are we paying $699,000 for mental health services when every school has at least one full time counselor. Also, each school is assigned a social worker and school psychologist (although they usually work at several schools).
Success for All
|
May 16, 2012
Most of the students that receive "mental health services" are from low income families and can't afford to see a licensed therapists, which is VERY different from a school counselor, on their own. These students absolutely need this service!
success works!
|
May 17, 2012
Success for All Students is a very beneficial program. These counselors work with the schools and visit the homes of the students to work bridging the gap for children with emotional issues. Many times the counselor helps the parents with their parenting skills, helps the parents to understand how they can help their child emotionally or academically, etc. The school guidance counselor does teaching in the classrooms and some crisis counseling with students. The social workers mostly work on tardies/absences, and DEFACS related issues.
Frankie58
|
May 16, 2012
OK...when TFA first came to light, we were told that it would be paid for with grants, then we were told that he was looking for local money, now he has to do "fundraising", and he may be using TFA sources, then "When asked whom he would be talking to about donating funds, he said he hasn’t made any moves". Then when asked about the trip to Florida he says "That money that we’re using (for the conference) is either coke machine money, foundation money or professional development money", coke machine money, really!!does the Board even know what this guy is doing or do they have there heads in the sand. He is hell bent on spending alot of money and doesn't or won't specify were it is all coming from, with a 62 million dollar defecit, is anyone on this Board going to remind him who he works for???
50 million oops
|
May 16, 2012
This is the same superintedent that spent 50 million over budget in Dallas. The school board is not qualified to hire a superintendent.
TIC
|
May 16, 2012
First of all a couple of disclaimers:

My kids are no longer in the Cobb Public School System.

I no longer pay the school millage portion on my property taxes.

So I really don't have a dog in this particular fight.

Now my completely objective comment.

Was this guy (Hinojosa) sent here from Texas to purposely sabotage our school system?

Cobb County has been a much admired and well accomplished public school system for many years. Certainly one of the top systems in Georgia (no big accomplishment there) but also one of the top public systems in the entire country.

What in the wide, wide world of sports is going on here?
frogbreath
|
May 16, 2012
TIC

When the school board chose Hinojosa, many folks checked his background and performance in Dallas. He left a bad taste in the Dallas schools, TFA, hiring undocumented for bilingual skills.

He has divided the community in the sense that the desperate are leaping on the let's tax seniors bandwagon, again.

In the past, that was the same thing that happened. Blindly, reach out and find a new away to tax or increase taxes as the drumbeat of threats of cutting teachers, hours, services, etc inspires fear in parents minds and they strike out blindly.

The luster of Cobb County schools has a big smear on it now. It was started by the administration and the board and is now being even more widely smeared by panicky parents.

How much tax would that family pay?? Maybe $2000?

Go ahead, make Cobb County less desirable for seniors like me. In good market times, I would sell and move somewhere that has the same plan that Cobb has today.

Like you, I felt I had no voice in these issues as I am getting the school tax write off , as a senior.

TIC
|
May 16, 2012
@ frog breath

Of course our biggest concern is how this fiasco is impacting our children and grandchildren (for us seniors) who attend Cobb County schools

But on a more personal note consider this:

In the past a not insignificant portion of our house value was attributable to being located in a county that had a highly rated school system.

Some school districts (i.e. Walton, Lassiter and Pope) contributed more to the value of our largest investments (our homes) than others, but overall the entire County benefited from the reputation of the school system.

As if the latest economic recession wasn't enough, now this joker (Hinojosa) is undercutting the value of our homes even more.

From Obama to Tim Lee to Hinojosa it seems all of our so called leaders are letting us down.

I am not whining, I am just pointing out the facts that slam us in the face with each and every day that passes.

I am determined to do what I can to turn this around come November.
Pay Up Seniors
|
May 16, 2012
@ frogbreath, trust me- that school tax is no easier for those under 62 to pay than it is for seniors to pay it. I hear lots of whining about seniors living on fixed incomes. Well, real wages have not gone up in over ten years and most folks no longer get a COLA in their salaries. Seniors do get a COLA adjustment unlike the rest of working population. Let's do away with that senior exemption now.
Sleepyhead2
|
May 16, 2012
PayupSeniors:

I'm really getting sick of reading your posts regarding us seniors paying up. I paid for decades and decades for my kids' school taxes as well as all the others. Quit your complaining and shut up - it's your turn to pay them. And when you grow up and get to be 62 or older, if you are fortunate enough not to die earlier than that, then you too will have earned this break. We seniors may not have to pay for school taxes any longer, but this is the first year in 3 that a COLA raise was even given - and for some it averaged a big $7 to 25 more per month. I'm sure that allowed them to immediately jet off to Monte Carlo (first class of course) and frolic with the rich and famous. I'm 66, work full time, have survived breast cancer and have mega medical co-pays for my testing and follow-ups, and raise a grand-child full time and cover her expenses as well as my own. So kindly put a sock in it, I'm tired of your bullspit.
no more sleepy heads
|
May 16, 2012
@sleepyhead2:

I'm not picking a fight, just asking a few questions:

1. What economic contributions do seniors make to the county? Being on fixed income, they may or may not have the resources to spend money on retail, restaurants, home improvements, etc. They are nice people, but fundamentally, the county needs its people to contribute financially, if not through property tax, then other economic measures. By drawing seniors to Cobb and permitting the tax break, we are actually losing significantly more revenue across the board.

2. If I am single or married without children, should I receive the tax exemption? The basic argument is, "I don't have kids in the schools anymore." With that premise, citizens without children should not be forced to pay for the schools, right? The problem with that is simple: good schools improve property values. If we don't contribute to the schools, our property values go down, whether we have kids or not. Don't you want the value of your house to stay high? I'm not sure it's fair to reap the benefits of something you no longer play a role in supporting.

3. Do Fulton and Gwinnett have the same revenue shortage? What is the tax exemption in those counties? What range of the population is senior status? Do you see a correlation between any of these figures?

Cuts can only take the school system so far. At this rate, we're asking teachers to manage close to 40 teenagers in a room fit for 25; it's crazy. I agree that cuts to top-level management are necessary, but revenue sources must be explored if we want to solve the crisis.
TIC
|
May 16, 2012
@ Pay Up Seniors

If you and your contemporaries would go to the voting booth and get rid of those CCSB members who are ruining our school system I would have no problem with paying the school millage portion of my tax bill.

As it is, I have to admit I am glad I'm not contributing to this wasteful and mismanaged fiasco being perpetrated on those of you who are paying.

You have my sympathies to a degree, but why don't you "man up" and take control of the situation at the ballot box before you start whining about seniors not paying over and above what they should be paying.

Otherwise as Sleepyhead2 said "Put a sock in it!!"

and

If you are, in fact, a Libertarian as you so proudly claim, then you shouldn't have a problem with an equitable user tax. If you use the service you pay the tax or fee, If you don't use the service you don't pay.

Pay Up Seniors
|
May 17, 2012
@ ITC, I vote in EVERY election and have already requested absentte ballots for upcoming elections! I'm doing my part.
Pay Up Seniors
|
May 19, 2012
@ TIC, I don't have a problem with a user tax or service fee at all. In fact, I would probably do away with the government service period and privatize EVERYTHING. Less government is better for all!
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides